Four Years — Four Lessons

Black Sea Security Forum — Special Meeting
Four Years of a Full-Scale War: What Worked, What Failed, What Comes Next

Marking four years since Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, the Special Meeting of the Black Sea Security Forum in Odesa brought together more than 70 high-level policymakers, senior military leaders, diplomats, members of parliament, security experts, and international journalists from the United States, the United Kingdom, Türkiye, Slovakia, Romania, and Bulgaria,Italy, including a delegation led by the Vice-President of the European Parliament.

The discussion focused on four key lessons of the war, assessing decisive strategic choices and future regional risks. Participants also met with local authorities, the Odesa Sea Port Administration, and local volunteers, gaining first-hand insight into maritime security and civilian resilience in wartime.

Panel Discussion 1: Innovation Wins Battles — Systems Win Wars

Ukraine proved that creativity can overturn military hierarchies — destroying a fleet without having one, redefining naval and drone warfare. But the next lesson was harsher: innovation without a system can hardly compete with mass, scale, and industrialization.

Dr. Hanna Shelest

Security Program Director, Ukrainian Prism

Roman Pohorilyi

Co-Founder, Deep State

Dominic Nicholls

Editor, The Telegraph

Amb. Kurt Volker

Distinguished Fellow, CEPA, U.S. Special Envoy for Ukraine (2017–2019)

Panel Discussion 2: Alliances Matter — Until They Don’t

Ukraine survived with its own resistance combined with partnerships and solidarity of its partners and allies. But four years of the full-scale war also revealed a harder truth: the global order is shifting, and ultimately every country is judged by its own strength.

Amb. Valeriy Chalyi

Ambassador of Ukraine to the US (2015–2019)

Amb. William Taylor

Distinguished Fellow at Atlantic Council’s Eurasia Center, former U.S. Ambassador to Ukraine

Dominic Nicholls

Editor, The Telegraph

Hon. Pina Picierno

Vice President, European Parliament

Gianni Vernetti

Former Senator and Undersecretary of Foreign Affairs of Italy

Agenda

Photos